Bretton Woods: a 'grotesque caricature'

Modern economics is experiencing a powerful resurgence of elegant inquiry into the classical gold standard... and its not so elegant variants. 

This resurgence is increasingly obvious from the academic literature.   And it is by no means of merely academic interest. 

One of the key sources, perhaps the primary source, of resistance among policy makers to resuming classical gold convertibility is the widespread misimpression that the gold standard was responsible for the Great Depression. 


Even though as respected a figure as Ben Bernanke has stated, as quoted here, that, "The proximate cause of the world depression was a structurally flawed and poorly managed international gold standard," the myth that the gold standard is dangerous to economic growth lingers, casting a cloak of mediocrity on the thinking of too many second-rate economists. It therefore is a breakthrough that first-rate thinkers such as Prof. Lawrence H. White, of the economics department of George Mason University, as well as, as recently referenced Prof. Lawrence H. Officer, of the University of Illinois at Chicago, are bringing world class analytical skills to the fore.

As acknowledged by Prof. Bernanke, there are ways to mismanage the international gold standard.  The late, great, French savant Jacques Rueff, intellectual inspiration for, famously referred to the gold-exchange standard as a "grotesque caricature" of the gold standard.  Implied in this was a warning that adopting, at Bretton Woods, the feckless pretense that the world had resumed the gold standard was quite dangerous.

Indeed, it proved to be so.  The inevitable decay and breakdowns of the Bretton Woods caricature would be, and were, falsely attributed to the true, classical, gold standard.  However well meaning the leadership of the Bretton Woods conference, collapsing a crucial distinction caused confusion to ensue in the thinking of later policy elites.

Prof. Lawrence H. White recently said in an important working paper, Bretton Woods and International Monetary Arrangements:

Before the First World War, under an international gold standard and a largely liberal trade regime, global commerce and investment had flourished. The 1920s and ’30s, by contrast, were chaotic. Adherence to the gold standard was spotty. National governments adopted mercantilist restrictions on trade and payments, triggering retaliations.


Of Prof. White’s many astute points perhaps most important is his clarification of the key distinction between the classical gold standard and the thoroughly disordered post-war monetary system whose breakdown was indeed a major contributing factor to the Great Depression.  At pages 376-377 is an especially welcome contribution, one needed to help restore an intelligent and constructive reappraisal of the gold standard as a modern policy option:


As a result the 1920s and ’30s were not decades of a restored classical gold standard, but of international monetary chaos. Leland Yeager has described the prevailing monetary policies this way: The gold standard of the late 1920s was hardly more than a facade. It involved extreme measures to economize on gold. . . . It involved the neutralization or offsetting of international influences on domestic money supplies, incomes, and prices. Gold standard methods of balance-of- payments equilibrium were largely destroyed and were not replaced by any alternative. . . . With both the price-and-income and the exchange-rate mechanisms of balance-of-payments adjustment out of operation, disequilibriums were accumulated or merely palliated, not continuously corrected.

Lawrence H. White is a professor of economics at George Mason University. Prior to position at George Mason, he was the F. A. Hayek Professor of Economic History in the Department of Economics, University of Missouri-St. Louis. He has been a visiting professor at the Queen's School of Management and Economics, Queen's University of Belfast, and a visiting scholar at the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta.

Professor White is the author of The Theory of Monetary Institutions (Blackwell, 1999), Free Banking in Britain (2nd ed., IEA, 1995), and Competition and Currency (NYU Press, 1989). He is the editor of several works, including The History of Gold and Silver (3 vols., Pickering and Chatto, 2000), The Crisis in American Banking (NYU Press, 1993), African Finance: Research and Reform(ICS Press, 1993), and Free Banking (3 vols., Edward Elgar, 1993). His articles on monetary theory and banking history have appeared in the American Economic Review, the Journal of Economic Literature, the Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking, and other leading professional journals.

Dr. White earned his PhD from the University of California, Los Angeles, and his AB from Harvard University.

Vinaora Nivo SliderVinaora Nivo SliderVinaora Nivo SliderVinaora Nivo Slider

An Exclusive Interview With Lewis E. Lehrman

June 22, 2015

An Exclusive Interview with Lewis E. Lehrman, Part Twenty-one


Signs Of The Gold Standard Emerging From Great Britain?

by Ralph Benko

... Given Kwarteng’s current and, likely, future importance to the world monetary discourse it really would be invaluable were he to master the arguments of Jacques Rueff, and of Lewis Lehrman, as well as those of Triffin (who shared the same diagnosis while offering a different prescription).

Read More



Exclusive interview with Prof. Lawrence White, Part 3

Ralph J. Benko  |  Oct 20, 2014
Lawrence H. White is an  economics professor at George Mason University who teaches graduate level monetary theory and policy. Lawrence White As described by the Wikipedia, "White earned his BA at Harvard University (1977) and PhD at the University of California at Los Angeles (1982). Before his current role at George Mason...
The Federal Reserve System's James Narron and David Skeie, career officials with the Federal Reserve System, are two eminent historically erudite figures.  Writing in the New York Federal Reserve Bank's online publication, Liberty Street Economics, they recently provided a continuation of their valuable historical "revue," Crisis Chronicles: The Collapse of the...
An article headline in Saturday’s Wall Street Journalread “Rate Talk Heats Up Within The Fed.” As Journalreporters Jon Hilsenrath and Michael Derby...
Jan 28, 2000
Key Monetary Writings
John D. Mueller

Jacques Rueff: Political Economist for the 21st Century?

My original plan, several months ago, was to do homage before the 20th century ended to the French economist Jacques...

Kathleen M. Packard, Publisher
Ralph J. Benko, Editor

In Memoriam
Professor Jacques Rueff

Now Available on Amazon and from The Lehrman Institute

Gold Standard 3-Pack

Three Gold Standard Titles for One Low Price. Only from The Lehrman Institute Store.

Buy from
The Lehrman Institute